Coffee · Reviews
The best mushroom coffee, according to 1,070 people who've tried more than one.
Most mushroom coffees taste terrible. We surveyed 1,070 of our subscribers — 69% came from another brand — and put the bestsellers side by side. Here's what we found.
As featured in
I have tried 3 other major brand mushroom coffees (the ones that pop up first when you search “mushroom coffee”) before getting Atlas+. This definitely tastes better than all the others.
Search “best mushroom coffee” and every brand claims the title. We make Atlas+ Superblend, so this page is our pitch — disclosure up top, no pretending otherwise.
The honest version: “best” depends on what you optimize for. So we surveyed 1,070 of our own subscribers (most of whom came from another brand) and put ourselves side-by-side with the two bestsellers. The result is below.
Two ways to try it
Pick the one that fits your morning.
Same supplement stack in both. Different cup.
For the purist
Superblend Coffee
Clean coffee taste. No sugar. Lowest calorie.
For the creamy crowd
Superblend Latte
Creamy coconut milk, touch of coconut sugar. Replaces the coffee-shop habit.
The four things buyers told us made or broke it.
Across 1,070 free-text survey responses, the same four things kept coming up. If a mushroom coffee fails on any of them, people quietly stop drinking it.
- Tastes like coffee, not dirt. 73 unprompted comments. Functional ingredients only work if you actually drink the cup.
- No stomach issues. 35 mentions. Most people come to mushroom coffee because regular coffee upsets their stomach. The mushroom version doing the same is a dealbreaker.
- Steady energy, no crash. 41 mentions. Lower caffeine paired with L-theanine, instead of a 95mg jolt that cliffs at 11am.
- Real functional doses. Named mushrooms and adaptogens at disclosed amounts — not “proprietary blend” hiding doses too small to do anything.
Atlas+ Superblend vs. two bestselling brands
Values current as of May 2026, sourced from each brand's product page. Bestsellers anonymized.
| Atlas+ Superblend |
Bestselling Brand 1 |
Bestselling Brand 2 |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Functional mushrooms | 3 | 6 | 2 |
| Caffeine per serving | ~45mg | ~48mg | ~45mg |
| L-theanine | ● | ○ | ● |
| Ashwagandha | ● | ○ | ○ |
| Collagen | ● | ○ | ● |
| Clinically-studied probiotic | ● | ○ | ○ |
| Vitamins D & B12 | ● | ○ | ○ |
The takeaway. Atlas+ is the only one with the full stack: collagen, a clinically-studied probiotic, vitamins D & B12, both adaptogens, and three functional mushrooms — disclosed at individual doses, not buried in a proprietary blend.
“Tastes good and no stomach upset like with regular coffee. So far very pleased with this product.”
77%
Average overall satisfaction: 4.26/5 across 1,457 subscribers and verified reviewers.
“I have been a somewhat snobbish coffee drinker for over 50 years. I tried Atlas Mushroom blend because of the ingredients and I wanted something to drink later in the day that wouldn't keep me awake. I'm hooked. I've stopped drinking my favorite coffee completely. A friend sent me another mushroom blend but it was so harsh I couldn't drink it.”
I love this stuff. I was expecting it to taste like dirt but it doesn't at all. It makes me feel calm and gives me energy at the same time. No crash. Will continue to buy this.
From the inbox & the feed
What buyers are sharing
What's in each cup
(Coffee or Latte)
Try Atlas+ — 30-day money-back guarantee
If you don't love your first order, you get your money back. No hoops.
Try With 50% Off →The “best mushroom coffee” depends on what you're optimizing for. If it's pure caffeine, you have stronger options. If it's a single drink that swaps in for your coffee, your collagen, your probiotic, and your multivitamin — and tastes good enough to drink for 90 days — that's what Atlas+ is built to be.
More from verified buyers
* These statements have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
† Benefits described are based on studies of the individual ingredients, conducted on populations that may differ from your own, and did not test our specific blend. Effects may vary.
© Atlas Coffee Club